Below is the list of players currently unavailable for transfer as they have been selected by 5 or more teams. The team names mentioned against certain players may differ due to transfers made by Premier League clubs, although they are correct on here for this competition.
| Player | Club | Value | Times Picked |
|---|---|---|---|
| GOALKEEPERS | |||
| P Cech | Chelsea | £3.9m | 14 |
| J Reina | Liverpool | £3.8m | 5 |
| S Given | Manchester City | £3.4m | 14 |
| DEFENDERS | |||
| N Vidic | Manchester United | £5.0m | 6 |
| J Terry | Chelsea | £4.8m | 5 |
| R Ferdinand | Manchester United | £4.7m | 7 |
| J Lescott | Everton | £4.6m | 7 |
| A Cole | Chelsea | £4.4m | 11 |
| P Evra | Manchester United | £4.2m | 12 |
| G Johnson | Liverpool | £4.0m | 13 |
| G Clichy | Arsenal | £3.8m | 8 |
| R Carvalho | Chelsea | £3.8m | 7 |
| T Vermaelen | Arsenal | £3.7m | 5 |
| W Bridge | Manchester City | £3.7m | 10 |
| M Richards | Manchester City | £3.5m | 7 |
| R Dunne | Manchester City | £3.1m | 5 |
| MIDFIELDERS | |||
| F Lampard | Chelsea | £7.0m | 14 |
| S Gerrard | Liverpool | £6.5m | 25 |
| A Arshavin | Arsenal | £5.5m | 31 |
| D Kuyt | Liverpool | £5.3m | 6 |
| C Fabregas | Arsenal | £5.0m | 7 |
| A Young | Aston Villa | £4.2m | 7 |
| S Ireland | Manchester City | £4.1m | 5 |
| M Arteta | Everton | £4.0m | 6 |
| A Lennon | Tottenham Hotspur | £3.7m | 5 |
| LA Valencia | Manchester United | £3.5m | 9 |
| T Cohen | Bolton Wanderers | £2.7m | 6 |
| STRIKERS | |||
| F Torres | Liverpool | £7.0m | 18 |
| W Rooney | Manchester United | £6.8m | 17 |
| D Drogba | Chelsea | £6.4m | 7 |
| E Adebayor | Manchester City | £6.2m | 6 |
| J Defoe | Tottenham Hotspur | £6.0m | 5 |
| D Bent | Tottenham Hotspur | £5.6m | 5 |
| C Cole | West Ham United | £5.4m | 5 |
| E da Silva | Arsenal | £5.3m | 7 |